Key takeaways
- Budget: electric cabinets and entry Pit Boss pellet grills. Expect functional controls, thinner steel and more manual cleanup.
- Mid-range: Traeger and Camp Chef pellet grills and larger vertical pellet cabinets. Expect better apps, richer accessory options and sturdier build.
- Premium: Weber Searwood and high-end gravity or American-built pellet units. Expect stronger searing, tighter insulation and longer support.
If you want a Masterbuilt-style set-and-forget smoker but with a different fuel or format, the strongest alternatives are pellet smokers from Weber, Traeger and Pit Boss for hands-off wood flavor, a Camp Chef pellet unit for people who want extra smoke character, and a vertical pellet cabinet from Pit Boss or Grilla for cooks who feed a crowd. Buyers who simply want a low-cost electric box can stay with a Masterbuilt-class electric smoker, since the brand still sells that format. The right swap depends on how much you want to spend, how much space you have, and how much you care about searing as well as smoking.
Why People Look Beyond Masterbuilt
Masterbuilt is best known for approachable smokers. Its own catalog lists digital electric models, a propane unit with a stated 960 square inches of cooking area, and a Gravity Series line of charcoal grill-smokers with a stated 225 to 700 degree Fahrenheit range and a Wi-Fi app. That breadth is the reason many first-time buyers start there. Shoppers tend to look elsewhere for a few common reasons: they want stronger smoke flavor than an electric element produces, they want a pellet hopper that feeds itself for a long cook, they want a bigger capacity, or they simply prefer another brand’s app, warranty or parts network.
It helps to name the trade-off up front. Electric smokers are simple, plug-in and usually the least expensive way to smoke. Pellet smokers add real wood combustion and often a searing option, but cost more and need power for the auger and controller. Charcoal and gravity-fed units give the most traditional flavor but ask more of you in cleanup. The alternatives below are grouped around those differences.
At a Glance: Current Alternatives Compared
| Model | Format | Best for | Stated specs (per maker or cited outlet) | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weber Searwood 600 | Pellet grill and smoker | Cooks who want smoke plus real searing | 648 sq in of cooking area (an XL version lists 972 sq in), 180 to 500 degree range per Smoked BBQ Source | Premium tier; shelves sold separately |
| Pit Boss 850 DX | Pellet grill | Budget-minded beginners | 840 sq in, 21 lb hopper, 180 to 500 degree range per Smoked BBQ Source | Limited direct-flame area; slower app setup reported |
| Traeger Woodridge Pro | Pellet grill | First-time pellet buyers who value the app | 970 sq in, 250 to 500 degree range per Smoked BBQ Source | Searing is weak; ash buildup reported |
| Camp Chef Woodwind Pro WiFi | Pellet grill with smoke box | Smoke-flavor seekers | Integrated smoke box, per roundup reviewers | Higher cost than basic pellet units |
| Pit Boss vertical pellet smoker | Vertical pellet cabinet | High capacity on a small footprint | Roundups cite roughly 1,830 sq in for one model | Less sear ability than a horizontal grill |
| Grilla Mammoth Vertical | Vertical pellet cabinet | Large groups, long cooks | 1,660 sq in (expandable), 40 lb hopper per Smoked BBQ Source | Reported to run noisily; no built-in handle |
| Masterbuilt digital electric (for reference) | Electric vertical | Lowest-effort entry smoking | Digital panel and side wood-chip loader per the maker | Less smoke depth than combustion fuels |
Weber Searwood 600: The Premium Pellet Pick
Smoked BBQ Source names the Weber Searwood 600 its best overall pellet grill and says it takes the place of the earlier SmokeFire line. Its stated cooking area is 648 square inches, with an extra-large version listed at 972. The reviewer praises its sear capability, quick heat recovery, adjustable smoke settings and add-ons such as a rotisserie and griddle. Drawbacks it lists include side and front shelves that are sold separately and grates that are less than ideal for searing.
This is the pick for someone leaving an electric smoker because they want one cooker for both low-and-slow brisket and a fast steak. It sits in the premium tier, so it makes sense mainly if you will use the grilling side often.
Pit Boss 850 DX: The Value Pellet Pick
Pit Boss shows up in several roundups as the budget-minded choice. Smoked BBQ Source names the 850 DX its best budget pellet grill, listing 840 square inches of cooking area, a 21 pound hopper and a probe-triggered keep-warm mode. It calls the hopper adequate for cooks of eight hours or more. Cons noted include limited direct-flame space, slow Wi-Fi setup and manual interior cleaning.
For Masterbuilt owners moving up in capability without moving up much in cost, this is the most direct step. You trade the plug-in simplicity of an electric box for pellets and a grill surface, but keep the digital control experience.
Traeger Woodridge Pro: The Beginner-Friendly Pellet Pick
Smoked BBQ Source calls the Traeger Woodridge Pro its beginner pick, listing 970 square inches, a 250 to 500 degree range, a well-regarded app and a rail system for upgrades. It also notes weak searing, ash buildup and no lid gasket. Another roundup describes Traeger as the priciest of the mainstream pellet brands. If app polish and a large accessory ecosystem matter more than raw value, Traeger is the common answer.
Camp Chef Woodwind Pro WiFi: Extra Smoke Character
One roundup rates the Camp Chef Woodwind Pro WiFi highly because of its integrated smoke box, which is meant to push more smoke flavor than a standard pellet burn. Pellet grills are sometimes criticized for mild smoke, so this feature is the reason to shortlist Camp Chef. The same roundup suggests the brand’s larger vertical model does not use its size as efficiently as the Pit Boss vertical, so choose the horizontal Woodwind if flavor is your priority.
Vertical Pellet Smokers for Capacity
If what you liked about a Masterbuilt was the cabinet shape, a vertical pellet smoker keeps that footprint while adding a self-feeding fuel system. Roundups cite a Pit Boss vertical model with about 1,830 square inches of cooking area, and Smoked BBQ Source lists the Grilla Mammoth Vertical at 1,660 square inches, expandable, with a 40 pound hopper and double-wall insulation. The same reviewer notes the Grilla runs noisily and lacks a built-in handle.
Vertical units are the better fit for ribs, sausages, jerky and large batches, and the weaker fit for searing. Plan for the cabinet’s height when choosing a spot, and allow clearance on all sides for heat.
Staying With Masterbuilt-Class Electric
An honest alternative is not to switch brands at all. Roundups still list the Masterbuilt 30-inch and 40-inch digital electric smokers among the best beginner choices, citing simple controls and widely available replacement parts. The maker’s own catalog lists a digital 40-inch model with a side wood-chip loader and a Wi-Fi-enabled 710 model with integrated probes. If your only frustration is a specific model, trading to a different Masterbuilt format, such as the propane ThermoTemp or a Gravity Series charcoal unit, may solve it without relearning a new cooker.
Budget Tiers Explained
- Budget: electric cabinets and entry Pit Boss pellet grills. Expect functional controls, thinner steel and more manual cleanup.
- Mid-range: Traeger and Camp Chef pellet grills and larger vertical pellet cabinets. Expect better apps, richer accessory options and sturdier build.
- Premium: Weber Searwood and high-end gravity or American-built pellet units. Expect stronger searing, tighter insulation and longer support.
Fit, Space and Safety Notes
- Measure your patio or deck before ordering. Vertical cabinets are tall, and horizontal pellet grills need side-shelf and lid clearance.
- Smokers produce carbon monoxide and hot surfaces. Use them outdoors only, away from walls, railings and overhangs, and follow the manual’s clearance guidance.
- Pellet units need a grounded outlet, and the manufacturer’s instructions on extension cords and weather protection apply. Ask a licensed electrician if you are unsure about outdoor power.
- Use food-grade cooking pellets only, and store them dry; damp pellets are a common cause of auger jams.
- Always use a probe thermometer and cook meats to the safe internal temperatures published by food safety authorities.
- Clean ash and grease regularly; grease buildup is a fire risk, and the maker’s cleaning schedule should be followed.
Pick X If You Want Y
| Pick this | If you want |
|---|---|
| Weber Searwood 600 | One cooker for smoking and proper searing, and you accept a premium tier |
| Pit Boss 850 DX | The lowest-cost route into pellet cooking with a large hopper |
| Traeger Woodridge Pro | A polished app and broad accessory range for a first pellet grill |
| Camp Chef Woodwind Pro WiFi | More smoke flavor than a typical pellet burn |
| Grilla Mammoth or Pit Boss vertical | Maximum rack space and long unattended cooks |
| Masterbuilt digital electric | The simplest, cheapest plug-in smoker and easy parts support |
Other Options Worth a Look
- Yoder YS640S: Smoked BBQ Source lists it as its high-end pick with 1,070 square inches, American construction and strong insulation; the tier is premium.
- Traeger Pro 34: a mainstream mid-tier Traeger described in one roundup as good value, with 884 square inches stated.
- Masterbuilt Gravity Series: if you like charcoal flavor and want fan-assisted temperature control, the maker lists a 225 to 700 degree range with app connectivity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a pellet smoker better than an electric smoker?
It depends on the goal. Pellet smokers burn real wood and often add a sear zone, so reviewers typically credit them with more flavor and flexibility. Electric smokers are simpler, usually cheaper and easier for a first cook.
Which alternative is best for a beginner?
Reviewers often point beginners to the Traeger Woodridge Pro for its app or the Pit Boss 850 DX for value. A basic digital electric smoker remains a valid beginner choice if you want minimal setup.
Do pellet grills smoke as heavily as charcoal or offset smokers?
Many reviewers say pellet smoke is milder. Features such as the Camp Chef smoke box and adjustable smoke settings on some Weber models are aimed at closing that gap, but purists may still prefer charcoal or stick burners.
How much cooking area do I need?
For a family, roughly 600 to 900 square inches covers most cooks. If you smoke multiple briskets or entertain large groups, the larger vertical cabinets in the 1,600 to 1,800 square inch range give more room.
Can I use these smokers on a covered patio?
Generally no. Smokers create carbon monoxide and need open ventilation and clearance from combustible surfaces. Follow the manual and local fire codes, and use them in open air only.
Are parts and support easy to find?
Major brands such as Traeger, Weber, Pit Boss, Camp Chef and Masterbuilt sell replacement parts directly. Warranty terms differ by model, so read the maker’s current terms for the exact unit before buying.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialA Prime membership for ages 18-24 with a trial period. Eligibility is set by Amazon.
See Prime for Young AdultsAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!